美國傳教組織虛構埋嬰視頻火爆Youtube

編者按：由美國傳教士協助攝製的一則「揭露」巴西印第安人活埋嬰兒習俗的短片在Youtube視頻分享網站獲得超過35萬次點擊觀看。然而有組織指出這則短片「純屬虛構」，意在醜化印第安人、挑起種族仇恨。

一則「揭露」巴西印第安人活埋嬰兒習俗的短片在Youtube視頻分享網站獲得超過35萬次點擊觀看。然而一家土著權利組織指出，這則短片「純屬虛構」，畫面中埋嬰所用「泥土」實為巧克力蛋糕。

不少人怒斥這則由美國傳教士協助攝製的短片意在醜化印第安人、挑起種族仇恨。

短片以一個名為「哈卡尼」的小女孩為主線，講述南美洲亞馬孫河流域一些印第安人部族活埋殘疾嬰幼兒的習俗。「哈卡尼」在當地語言中意為「微笑」。根據這段視頻，這個女孩出生兩年後仍不會說話或行走，成為部族成員眼中「沒有靈魂的人」，以至面臨遭活埋命運。

她的父母因不忍心下手而選擇雙雙自殺，埋嬰任務便落到她長兄和爺爺肩頭。哈卡尼幾度陷入險境，但終於逃得一命、在部族之外漂泊度日。

片中多次出現當地成年人甚至兒童往嬰兒身上撒土、部族成員赤腳示範如何踩實泥土、被埋嬰兒頂著鬆軟泥土掙扎等鏡頭，可謂極富震撼力。

不少人在視頻網頁留言表達自己的震驚和憤慨。

然而國際維護土著權利組織怒斥這則短片捏造事實，有惡意醜化印第安人之嫌。

這家總部位於英國首都倫敦的機構發表聲明說：「事實上，（片中）蓋在兒童臉上的泥土是巧克力蛋糕，而影片關於殺嬰乃巴西印第安人普遍做法的說法並不真實。」

短片由美國傳教組織「青年使命團」創始人之子戴維·洛倫·坎寧安導演。這一傳教組織總部位於夏威夷，主要面向青年人傳音佈道。

攝製人員伊諾克·弗雷里向路透社記者承認，短片在青年使命團協助下攝製，雖然虛構情節，但力求吸引人們關注亞馬孫河流域印第安人部族殺嬰這一嚴重問題。

新華社記者 楊舒怡

>> 更多視頻

問題是這類問題到底有沒有？

然後就是你聽那個所謂的土著組織的，認為是虛構，還是聽聽無辜嬰兒的哭聲，力所能及地防止悲劇？

有啊，可以真實報道。
如果是拍電影，就應該說明是拍電影。
模糊文藝作品和真實記錄的做法不可取。

大象無形 發表於 2009-3-22 06:56
有啊，可以真實報道。
如果是拍電影，就應該說明是拍電影。
模糊文藝作品和真實記錄的做法不可取。

拍這種影片的組織應定為邪教組織。

拎不清 發表於 2012-2-14 12:54
拍這種影片的組織應定為邪教組織。

裝神弄鬼的又不是一個兩個，各有各的巧妙而已，沒被抓出來的多了。

那些所謂的見證，其實和影片有異曲同工之處。

回復 催肥 7樓 的帖子

Government accusations

Vaz recently completed an investigation into Youth With A Mission. His report accuses the group of "hiding their intent to evangelize" and bribing tribe members with tools and medicine to get them to listen to the Gospel.

The report, without elaboration, accuses the missionaries of slavery, illegally taking blood samples from Indians and illegally removing Indian children.

Braulia Ribeira, who runs YWAM's operations in the Amazon, denies the allegations. "I think they threw as many accusations as they could, hoping that at least one of them would stick," she says.

"They are trying to take the focus off the problems," Marcia Suzuki says. "Children are being killed, hundreds, in very cruel ways … but the government is trying to distract people and say, 'No, it's not the problem. The problem is the missionaries.' "

The missionaries deny that they are using infanticide as a smokescreen for efforts to convert Indians. YWAM members, including Marcia and Edson Suzuki, often live with tribes for decades, learning their ancient languages and providing health care and education. Despite their religious orientation, Ribeira says, they do not proselytize. "Our main mission," she says, "is to provide access to means of survival."

At one site where YWAM works, deep in the jungle near Porto Velho, an Indian girl wears a Jesus T-shirt.

Francisca Irving, one of the missionaries working there, admits preaching the gospel to Indians. "Yes, we teach Jesus," she says. "I would lie if I told you we didn't talk about Jesus."

The legislative push against infanticide is gaining steam in the Brazilian legislature. One house of the Brazilian legislature has passed a bill that would allow children whose lives are "at risk due to cultural practices" to be removed from their homes.

Vaz says the Department of Indian Affairs is developing a policy.

"Infanticide is a serious issue, which needs to be discussed," he says. But "this is not a discussion that must only be seen through the Christian perspective."

Dan Harris is an anchor/correspondent with ABC News
http://www.usatoday.com/news/world/2008-09-22-infanticide_N.htm

大象無形 發表於 2009-3-22 05:54
編者按：由美國傳教士協助攝製的一則「揭露」巴西印第安人活埋嬰兒習俗的短片在Youtube視頻分享網站獲得超過 ...

「短片在Youtube視頻分享網站獲得超過35萬次點擊觀看」
我Youtube視頻分享網站看了，沒有找到這個說法的根據。這個說法有根據嗎？

我看見短片的片頭有這樣的提示：
It includes faked footage (a 're-enactment') of an Amazon tribe burying a child alive.

短片一看就是錄製的影片，很少人會以為這是原現場紀實錄像。

（本非表示完全同意參與活動的各種組織的做法）

張藝謀南京大屠殺新片引熱議 日本網民否認歷史
http://news.sohu.com/20091217/n269023212.shtml

張藝謀虛構南京大屠殺影片，能夠成為否認南京大屠殺的根據嗎？

南美洲亞馬孫河流域一些印第安人部族活埋殘疾嬰幼兒的習俗和名為「哈卡尼」的小女孩的故事並非空穴來風。

巴西政治人士目前正在對一份禁止殺嬰的法案草案展開辯論。它也被稱作穆瓦基(Muwaji)法案，是以一名蘇魯瓦哈婦女的名字命名的，她曾拒絕活埋自己的孩子。

Brazil – 「Muwaji Law」, for the right to life
http://grassrootsnews.tv/?p=936

Today in Brazil, the bill 1057 known as 「Muwaji Law」, was approved at the Human Rights Committee at the National Congress, which seeks to protect indigenous children at risk for being born with physical or mental disability, being twins, daughters of single mother or for other reasons determined by the tradition of each indigenous people. In some ethnic groups such children are still at risk of being rejected, abandoned in the woods or killed by members of the family, due to internal pressure. In some of these communities there are reports of more than 200 children killed in these conditions.

The bill was named after Muwaji, the first indigenous mother from a remote tribe called.

Muwaji and her daughter Iganani suruwahá, in the Amazon, who fought for her daughter』s life who was born with cerebral palsy, going against the traditions of her tribe of burying the baby alive. After her, many other indigenous families were inspired to fight for their children』s rights to live.


亞馬遜流域發現"殺嬰部落" 每年活埋幾十名嬰兒
http://sci.ce.cn/history/01/200706/25/t20070625_11923432.shtml

360軍事網
http://www.360js.com/shehuiminsheng/qiwendieshi/20111110/921.html

中國地理網
http://news.chinageo.com/html/cngeo/wordgeo/20090206/46428.html

來源：星島環球網
http://:82/geography/200706/t20070625_563672.html

Girl survived tribe's custom of live baby burial

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/ ... ve-baby-burial.html