倍可親

什麼車最安全---汽車的質量和安全性。

作者:kissmyaaa  於 2011-12-25 17:07 發表於 最熱鬧的華人社交網路--貝殼村

通用分類:熱點雜談|已有2評論

常往國內跑的人都知道, 大款們偏愛德國產的賓士和寶馬。以至於在美國的華人里也有很多人已擁有寶馬和賓士為榮。更有中國成就了德國的出口之說。 其實這是華人的一個很大的誤會。
華人向來沒有政府和民間機構對產品及品牌有一個透徹的分析, 於是乎長期以來就是賣最貴的為榮,男人炫耀寶馬賓士, 女人偏愛LV , 好像能買得起就是身份的象徵。 
下面的文章里是來自美國權威機構對汽車品牌的評價, 主要是在安全,質量等可靠性進行綜合評比, 也許對很多人的觀念是個顛覆。 這個評比的結論是, 德國車基本上是一個在設計新穎和採用新科技上比較領先, 但是在產品的實用性上, 即關鍵的質量和安全性上, 都不處在領先地位。 



This list shows the factors that car owners consider important when buying a new car. The percentage is based on the number of respondents who said the factor was among their top three priorities. We've included last year's figures to show changes, though only the environmentally friendly/green factor had a significant shift.
Factor20112010
Safety65%64%
Quality5758
Value5151
Performance4745
Environmentally friendly/green2832
Design/style2526
Technology/innovation1715

We approach this question in two ways: Asking for the top three factors and separately, requesting the single, top factor. Either way, the order remained the same.

Where we did find differences was between the sexes. Women considered safety (74 percent versus 56 percent of men) and environmentally friendly/green (33 percent versus 22 percent of men) far more important, while men put more emphasis on value (54 percent versus 47 percent of women).

Safety

Brand2011Brand2010
Volvo70%Volvo73%
Ford20Ford22
Honda17Subaru21
Subaru17Toyota18
Mercedes-Benz14Honda17
These are the top five brands that car owners consider the best in this category. The accompanying percentage reflects those respondents who are aware of the brand and named the brand as their No. 1 choice in safety. The results from 2010 are presented for comparison.

Volvo continues to dominate the Safety category, with a dramatic 50-point advantage over Ford, in second place. That margin elevates the Chinese-owned brand to Top 10 status overall. Without leadership in this factor, Volvo would blend in with second-tier brands in consumers' minds. Still, Volvo slid a bit in the safety category this year. The movement may be because Volvo has not played the safety drumbeat as loudly as in the past during the transition to new ownership.

Other brands lost ground, but only slightly and without statistical significance. It is possible that in the year ahead, the results from the more-stringent government crash-test rating system may influence future perceptions. Among the 2011 models tested thus far, only the Honda Accord has earned five stars across the board—a feat that was commonplace just a year ago.

Quality
Brand2011Brand2010
Honda25%Toyota30%
Ford23Honda25
Toyota19Ford22
Chevrolet16Chevrolet18
Mercedes-Benz15Mercedes-Benz16
These are the top five brands that car owners consider the best in this category. The accompanying percentage reflects those respondents who are aware of the brand and named the brand as their No. 1 choice in quality. The results from 2010 are presented for comparison.

What a difference a year makes. Toyota lost its grip on the hard-won reputation for quality with a series of recalls that affected millions of vehicles over the last 18 months. For a company whose processes were scrutinized for decades by the competition and taught in colleges, this is a tough blow.

In our latest reliability survey (which included 1.3 million vehicles), Toyota dropped three places to rank sixth overall for reliability. Even the usually impressive Prius hybrid lost ground, earning just an "average" predicted reliability score.

In contrast, Honda and Ford ranked higher than Toyota, each without a single model showing reliability below or merely at the industry average.

Aside from Toyota, the quality leaders in the Brand Perception survey remain consistent. Of those top five, only Mercedes-Benz's appearance among them shows how perception differs from reality. While most Mercedes models fare well in our tests and are enjoyable to drive, the brand ranks 22nd in predicted reliability—down four spots from the previous year.

Value
Brand2011Brand2010
Ford25%Honda26%
Honda24Toyota26
Toyota23Ford22
Hyundai17Chevrolet21
Chevrolet15Hyundai20
These are the top five brands that car owners consider the best in this category. The accompanying percentage reflects those respondents who are aware of the brand and named the brand as their No. 1 choice in value. The results from 2010 are presented for comparison.

We see year-to-year movement for most brands in the survey, suggesting that the rollout of new models and their associated marketing campaigns can affect consumer perception.

Consistent what we've seen elsewhere in this survey, consumers' perception of Toyota has dropped while their perception of Ford has risen. Honda comes in a respectable second.

While the term "value" can be open to personal interpretation, it is clear that car buyers are looking to get the most for their money, including a good car at a good price. Value-conscious car shoppers can find significant savings on Consumer Reports-recommended vehicles. 

Performance

Brand2011Brand2010
BMW27%BMW29%
Porsche21Porsche26
Ford19Toyota22
Chevrolet19Chevrolet21
Audi17Ford19
These are the top five brands that car owners consider the best in this category. The accompanying percentage reflects those respondents who are aware of the brand and named the brand as their No.1 choice in performance. The results from 2010 are presented for comparison.

BMW and Porsche continue to reign as the performance leaders year after year. Their reputation is well deserved, as products from those two German automakers consistently deliver a sporty character. The cars typically do well in our dynamic tests, with strong acceleration and agile handling. While entertaining to drive, several BMW models are not recommended by Consumer Reports due to below-average reliability.

Ford claims third place in performance, with Toyota falling from the top five. The story is more that Toyota tumbled to 15 percentage points, rather than that Ford made great strides, as its score remains unchanged. Last year, we were quite impressed by the updated Mustang and its more powerful V6 and V8 engines.

Toyota's high scores in past years suggest that survey respondents were reacting to more than track-based performance characteristics in their strong support for the brand. It has been a long time since the Toyota brand had a true performance car. The days of the Celica and Supra are well behind us, replaced by the hybrid era that has served the company well. Much of the recent recall news about Toyota surrounded issues related to unintended acceleration, brake issues, and accelerator pedal problems. It may be that when it came to performance in the past, consumers weren't strictly focused on acceleration and handling with Toyota, but today they may be concerned with stopping.

Audi made the cut this year, climbing 8 percentage points over last year—a major improvement. A growing portfolio with high-performance S model variants and an R8 supercar flagship is clearly communicating that there is another performance-focused German automaker.

Environmentally friendly/green
Brand2011Brand2010
Toyota46%Toyota51%
Ford18Honda23
Honda17Ford19
Chevrolet12Chevrolet13
Scion9Subaru8
These are the top five brands that car owners consider the best in this category. The accompanying percentage reflects those respondents who are aware of the brand and named the brand as their No. 1 choice in environmentally friendly/green. The results from 2010 are presented for comparison.

Given the attention the Chevrolet Volt, Nissan Leaf, and other electrified cars are getting, you might think that environmentally friendly cars would be a market force. But our recent green car survey showed that while Americans want better fuel efficiency, they are not willing to pay extra for it. Times are tough for many people and the green that matters most these days is money.

Consumers are aware that all automakers are striving to improve their models' fuel economy, and expectations are high for the next new car purchase. This year, we're seeing the green factor reflect that Toyota and Honda no longer have exclusive leadership in this area. While both companies provide several hybrid models and offer other fuel-efficient vehicles, the competition is making significant strides.

The second-ranked Ford now has its Fusion hybrid sedan and it has been spreading its turbocharged "EcoBoost" engines across several model ranges, delivering more power and efficiency than before.

Chevrolet is making its fuel-economy push with the Cruze, Equinox, Volt, and coming Sonic.

This year Scion has entered the top ranks at No. 5, edging out sixth-place Subaru and well ahead of Hyundai at No. 7. The surprising result here is based on official EPA fuel economy ratings; Hyundai would be a green factor leader. It will take time for perception to catch up with this reality. As Hyundai rolls out the Sonata hybrid, redesigned Elantra, and eventually the small Veloster, it may capture more green awareness.

Design/style
Brand2011Brand2010
BMW22%Lexus23%
Porsche20Cadillac23
Cadillac20Mercedes-Benz23
Mercedes-Benz18Chevrolet19
Lexus17BMW19
These are the top five brands that car owners consider the best in this category. The accompanying percentage reflects those respondents who are aware of the brand and named the brand as their No. 1 choice in design/style. The results from 2010 are presented for comparison.

When it comes to cars, styling is ultimately in the eye of the beholder, and consumers have crowned BMW as the winner. Along with BMW, the other top-ranked brands for design and style this year are also prestigious luxury brands.

There has been some movement in the design factor, with Lexus and Cadillac moving down from last year. Both brands continue to drop since 2008. Lexus has dropped 15 points in two years, and Cadillac has dropped 6 points.

Last year, Toyota had 17 points, and this year it came in with just 10. The drop in perceived styling leadership contributes to that brand's reduced overall score. This change cannot be blamed on safety concerns or headlines.

Just off our leader chart, Ford claimed 17 points this year, followed by Chevrolet with 16.

Over time, we're seeing less dominance for this factor, with points increasingly spread among many brands.

Technology/innovation
Brand2011Brand2010
Toyota22%Toyota32%
Mercedes-Benz22Mercedes-Benz21
Ford21Lexus19
Lexus18Ford18
BMW17Honda17
These are the top five brands that car owners consider the best in this category. The accompanying percentage reflects those respondents who are aware of the brand and named the brand as their No. 1 choice in technology/innovation. The results from 2010 are presented for comparison.

Toyota lost its significant lead in technology/innovation this year, leaving the top five brands all clustered with similar scores. In the past, Toyota had a commanding advantage in technology, most likely fueled by its hybrid powertrains and related marketing. As competitors roll out their own hybrid vehicles, electrified cars are no longer perceived as the exclusive domain of Toyota.

It would seem that consumers now take the Prius for granted and potentially are not impressed with the Honda CR-Z and Insight. (That's OK; Consumer Reports isn't impressed with those Honda hybrids, either.) Honda was bumped off the short list with just 14 percentage points this year.

Ford has inched up this year, with numerous recent innovations to its credit beyond hybrid and EcoBoost powertrains. The SYNC driver interface system continues to evolve, and it has spawned MyFord Touch, a customer-configurable touch-screen display that integrates with smart phones to share data using Bluetooth. On the truck side, the Works Solutions option provides handy features for commercial users, including an RFID tool inventory tracker and GPS-enabled fleet management.

Lexus and BMW make the list, with each offering powerful, modern powertrains and advanced safety features.

Just off this list is Chevrolet at 11 points. With the coming Volt and new models in the pipeline, this is a brand to watch for next year.

Two prestige brands that weren't close, Infiniti (8) and Acura (5), focus engineering and marketing efforts heavily on high-tech features. Perception is a powerful influence, but this reminds that again, it is worth looking beyond pre-conceived notions and advertising copy to learn about the cars to see if they excel in the areas that matter most to you.


高興

感動

同情

搞笑

難過

拍磚

支持
4

鮮花

剛表態過的朋友 (4 人)

發表評論 評論 (2 個評論)

回復 lzh112 2011-12-25 20:45
2010 和2011 同樣牌子的QUALITY 排名變化劇烈,這個只是根據OWNER的感覺而不是嚴格的測試。在汽車工業中很難令人信服的。因為汽車的生產不像電子產品更新很快。汽車生產的設計和工藝變動很小(除非某種型號)。結論是排名根據車主的印象感覺,所以不靠譜。
回復 gpan1975 2012-1-12 10:12
我以前在急診工作。什麼樣的車禍我都見過。

天底下哪有真正安全的車?在車禍面前,美國車、日本車之間的區別就如同雞蛋撞石頭與鴨蛋撞石頭之間的區別一樣。

良好的駕駛習慣才是最關鍵的。

facelist doodle 塗鴉板

您需要登錄后才可以評論 登錄 | 註冊

關於本站 | 隱私權政策 | 免責條款 | 版權聲明 | 聯絡我們

Copyright © 2001-2013 海外華人中文門戶:倍可親 (http://big5.backchina.com) All Rights Reserved.

程序系統基於 Discuz! X3.1 商業版 優化 Discuz! © 2001-2013 Comsenz Inc.

本站時間採用京港台時間 GMT+8, 2024-4-25 23:59

返回頂部