不覺得孔教授說的有什麼錯。
幾十年後回頭再看抗美援朝這場戰爭，絕對是必要的。當時的中國不只是試圖從昔日的屈辱和落後中站起身來， 而且還努力地想在列強包圍擠壓中走出自己的路子來。這時自信心尤為重要。這一仗就是打出了自信心，才有了後來的退出聯合國，和蘇老大決裂，終結世界核子壟斷等。我不是說，這一切皆源於韓戰的結果。 但是， 韓戰的結局提供了強大的心理支撐依據。老毛不是神人。但是他很注重過往的經驗。
對孔教授說的雙方人員傷亡的具體數目不完全贊同。但這不妨礙支持他的觀點。
人往往愛走極端。不是盲目跟從瞎激動，就是全盤否定，一無是處。我堅決力挺愛惜生命這一文明理念。但是， 當一個生命和一個國家/民族的利益，尊嚴和戰略目標相碰撞時，生命只能在很大程度上服從這些目標。 任何一個國家都是這樣做的。中國是這樣，美國更是這樣。想想越南戰爭，入侵伊拉克。無論以什麼理由和借口，戰死沙場的一個個生命都服務於各自的目的。當然，各自的目的/目標又決定其死亡「或重於泰山，或輕於鴻毛。」
就事論事，這場戰爭之於中國人，值。
願所有命喪於斯的人們能夠安息。不管是中國的還是美國的還是其他國家的。
幾十年後回頭再看抗美援朝這場戰爭，絕對是必要的。當時的中國不只是試圖從昔日的屈辱和落後中站起身來， 而且還努力地想在列強包圍擠壓中走出自己的路子來。這時自信心尤為重要。這一仗就是打出了自信心，才有了後來的退出聯合國，和蘇老大決裂，終結世界核子壟斷等。我不是說，這一切皆源於韓戰的結果。 但是， 韓戰的結局提供了強大的心理支撐依據。老毛不是神人。但是他很注重過往的經驗。
對孔教授說的雙方人員傷亡的具體數目不完全贊同。但這不妨礙支持他的觀點。
人往往愛走極端。不是盲目跟從瞎激動，就是全盤否定，一無是處。我堅決力挺愛惜生命這一文明理念。但是， 當一個生命和一個國家/民族的利益，尊嚴和戰略目標相碰撞時，生命只能在很大程度上服從這些目標。 任何一個國家都是這樣做的。中國是這樣，美國更是這樣。想想越南戰爭，入侵伊拉克。無論以什麼理由和借口，戰死沙場的一個個生命都服務於各自的目的。當然，各自的目的/目標又決定其死亡「或重於泰山，或輕於鴻毛。」
就事論事，這場戰爭之於中國人，值。
願所有命喪於斯的人們能夠安息。不管是中國的還是美國的還是其他國家的。
- [09/02]我正在城樓觀山景
- [01/16]剛收到的段子。搞笑！
- [01/18]聽說台灣圓山飯店上了香艷大腿舞
- [01/28]雪山一支蒿
- [01/29]數票子
- [01/30] 讀孔慶東在韓國講抗美援朝
- [02/10]考古新發現的新發現
- [02/14]門聯
- [02/15]阿慶嫂又當如何
- [02/23]龍吟虎嘯迎春到
- [03/11]江湖追殺令續
- [03/16]曝料，爆炒腰花
- [04/12]亂翻書
發表評論 評論 (19 個評論)
- 回復 陽關
- snortbsd: visited the war museum in soul and it was pretty interesting experience.去現場了解他們的想法一定很有意思的
- 回復 snortbsd
- 陽關: 去現場了解他們的想法一定很有意思的actually the seoul war museum was very nicely constructed. a lot of displays of weaponry.
right next to the biggest american base in south korea...
- 回復 穿鞋的蜻蜓
- snortbsd: seoul, typo...well i didn't really care so much about how seoul is spelt as your 'interesting experience' at that museum:)
- 回復 snortbsd
- 穿鞋的蜻蜓: well i didn't really care so much about how seoul is spelt as your 'interesting experience' at that museum:)hmm, the brave south korea soldiers fought brilliantly against human tides and waves of the red chinese. of course a lot of pictures of those captured chinese soldiers were the powerful proofs for that. interestingly not that many pictures of north korea pows as i expected.... in reality, more north korea pows than chinese ones
i followed a group of tourists with tour guide. one american woman asked the chinese scripts in some pictures, the tour guide gave out a quick answer:"those were ancient korean writing"...
...
- 回復 陽關
- 遙祝: 我在酒吧上班著,用的是小小的筆記本電腦,打字很吃力,所以一般喜歡用笑臉表示我贊同你的想法等等,給你帶來疑惑不好意思哈好樣的！ 一手抓革命， 一手促生產。
以後有機會一定來拜訪你的酒吧， 是不是門上支了一個酒幌子： 三碗不過崗
- 回復 陽關
- 馬大哈ann: 沒看過他的講演，但是你的說法我完全贊同。一切要從歷史的角度看問題。。。中國能有今天第一代共產黨人作出了巨大的貢獻。。。同感。做對了就應該正確評價。
沒做對的就不跟他們摻和。
- 回復 穿鞋的蜻蜓
- snortbsd: hmm, the brave south korea soldiers fought brilliantly against human tides and waves of the red chinese. of course a lot of pictures of those captureThanks！That IS interesting. I heard the similar stuff (human tides and waves)from a Chinese man (said was son of former cook of SK prez.李承晚 and invented the most popular seafood flavored noodle炸醬麵 in that country） from South Korea,the same guy also told me how nastily Koreans had treated Chinese there (in school,restaurant,etc.) they are really narrow-minded meanies who are shamelessly desperate to get ahead beyond the limit.
- 回復 snortbsd
- 穿鞋的蜻蜓: Thanks！That IS interesting. I heard the similar stuff (human tides and waves)from a Chinese man (said was son of former cook of SK prez.李承晚 and iwell, i didn't have problems with koreans in general, plus i stayed in bases in most of my time over there.
yes south koreans i met were kinda overly sensitive regarding their images. the issue of "saving face" is much, much worse than that of chinese, in general.
one of misunderstandings of casualties for UN side was the elements of american fight units in korea. for at least half of american fighting units were/are koreans (so called KATUSA soldiers). they were/are korean citizens. together with americans, they form a fighting unit. say a company, there could be more than half of koreans....
- 回復 穿鞋的蜻蜓
- snortbsd: well, i didn't have problems with koreans in general, plus i stayed in bases in most of my time over there.i have no problems dealing with them either just a little side comment. some of the comments were told by non-asians(black for example) before I got the first hand impressions afterwords.
yes south koreans i met were kinda over
Thanks for the info regarding the US/SK casualities.
The truth about casulties of Korean War is like a messy mirror ,we can get as much as we can make out--- all i know is there have been manipulations on both sides for the sake of self serving propaganda--it's only natural and necessary perhaps.
陽關最受歡迎的博文
其它[其它日誌]博文更多
- kylelong：英文化驗單的參考值範圍
- kylelong：如何看懂英文的驗血化驗單？
- kylelong：小說：永遠的巨蟹座愛人（下集）
- kylelong：頭頂漩渦與指紋漩渦的旋轉方向
- kylelong：世界各地的粽子集錦
- kylelong：關於「諾貝爾獎勵基金」的事實與推理
- kylelong：媽媽咪語錄大全
- kylelong：女人如書
- kylelong：愛情工程流程詳解
- kylelong：腦神經疾病的預防與食療
- kylelong：生命中的休止符
- kylelong：雪花兒要看的「老婆餅」
- kylelong：人在旅途
- kylelong：人民幣是如何印刷出來的
- kylelong：愛
- kylelong：Rudolph，紅鼻子馴鹿的聖誕吉祥物
- kylelong：知心愛人
- 翰山：辯證反思6.4：主要應該政府負責
- kylelong：綠色熒光蛋白轉基因魚的發育過程（2）
- kylelong：綠色熒光蛋白轉基因魚的發育過程（1）