在飛行員協會的工作
---國家駕聯關於Akara-Fukue空中走廊及RVSM的討論
在各國專家討論的後期,由於事關中日韓以及周邊路過飛機的航空安全,大家就Akara-Fukue空中走廊的問題進行了集中全面地討論。
目前的現狀是,這個區域,ICAO劃歸給仁川情報區,但是實際管轄權在日本。韓國一直要求將管轄權歸還韓國,日本一直堅持不給。問題是南北向的飛機B576、B586飛機以及在A593航路上出入韓國的飛機主要是由韓國指揮,A593航路上的飛機是由日本指揮,所以在這個走廊要求飛機不能改變高度,在這個航路經常出現臨近飛機右不同的國家的管制區指揮的情況,正常情況下沒事,應急情況下就有很大的潛在危險。
在諮詢我的意見的時候,我諮詢了一些管制員和業內人士,大家的意見,主要是我們主張是SADLI是我們的邊界,但是ICAO從lamen以外都划給仁川,對於SADLI以外的區域中國也從未主張。所以我個人的建議是,這個問題主要是韓國和日本之間協調,希望你們兩個飛行員協會敦促各自民航主管機構協調管制權,形成統一的管理,保障安全飛行。
後來,日本飛行員協會僅就日本的立場,在這方面對這個走廊的歷史進行了一些闡述,在這裡發給大家,以期大家對此問題的背景有一個了解。(他們的觀點是中國政府和韓國政府的問題,推託了日本的介入)
Dear Stu and
all,
ALPA Japan had a meeting with JCAB on Akara-Fukue
Corridor and Chinese RVSM on 15th. Persons who attended
from JCAB were Mr. Yoshiki Imawaka, Director for International
Policy Coordination ATS Systems Planning Division, and Natsuki Ibe,
Chief, Operations Section, Air Traffic Control Division.
Imawaka is a
person whom Stu met in the last DGCA meeting.
Our members
were Koichi Sano (former RVP NOP), Tsutomu Mizozoe (Chairman of ATS
Committee), Daisuke Otsuka (member of ATS Committee) and
I.
The meeting was finished in very friendly and
productively mood. We clearly understood this AKARA-FUKUE Corridor
problem is a political issue between Chinese and Korean
Governments. Imawaka explained the history on this corridor at the
beginning.
When A593 was established by strong request of IATA
on 1983, the problem of FIR boundary was not completely cleared.
Korean Government recognized the west boundary of Taegue FIR
(former name of Incheon FIR) was 125 degrees E (LAMEN) that had
been confirmed by ICAO before China joined ICAO.
But Chinese
Government had insisted 124 degrees E (SADLI) to be the East
boundary of Chinese FIR after China joined ICAO.
But Chinese
Government agreed the west boundary was LAMEN when established
A593. However Chinese Government still sticks to
the east boundary to be SADLI even now. So, when discussing the
revision of the agreement of AKARA-FUKUE Corridor, it can』t be
carried without touching FIR boundary. When discussing FIR
boundary, only the highest political judgment seems to solve the
problem.
And even
discussing new lower altitude in this corridor means the revision
of the agreement for both Chinese and Korean
Governments.
Imawaka said
that he can't understand why Shanghai control doesn't approve
crossing LAMEN at FL230 or above reaching FL250 by SADLI. It'll be
better to ask this question to Chinese CAA from ALPA
China.
Metric RVSM
in A593 would be impossible to implement without solving many
problems on this route.
China wants to increase traffic on A593 because of
Beijing Olympic and the International Trade Fair in Shanghai,
etc. Also the traffic between Korea and Hong Kong
via Cheju VOR to join A593 at NIRAT and the traffic vice versa are
growing in several years. There』s no direct communication line
between Incheon control and Shanghai control, Fukuoka control is
relaying those traffic information to Incheon control and Shanghai
control.
There exist
some conditions in both China and Korea that will work to solve
this problem. But we seem to have nothing of effective measure at
present time.
Sharing information of ALPA China vs Chinese CAA
and ALPA Korea vs Korean CAA will help other bodies to drive this
issue. I want to keep a closed communication in possible
range.
Some more about the history
At the very
beginning this area was Japanese FIR. After the World War Second,
all ATC system was under the rule of US Army in Japan and Korea.
When finishing the rule of US Army, Korean Government insisted
supported by US Army to change this area into Taegue FIR like
present form. Japanese Government opposed this proposal but it was
adopted by majority at ICAO Meeting on 1962.
Then the
friendship between China and Japan was reestablished September
1972. Since the friendship between China and Korea was not
established at that time, the first flight (August 1974) between
Tokyo and Beijing took the route A1 via Kagoshima detouring Taegue
FIR to the south and went up to north via Shanghai. Then it was
shortened a little on1980 detouring to the south of the Thaeg FIR
via Fukue. Further shorten airway A593 was established on
1983.
Kind regards,
Tsutomu Ishiyama
Link URL:
http://blog.sina.com.cn/u/59223c7f01000be0