肖傳國的國外支持者「國際學術同仁」公然歪曲捏造事實

來源：新語絲
10.10.15

肖傳國的國外支持者「國際學術同仁」公然歪曲捏造事實
　　——評所謂「國際學術同仁聲援肖傳國醫生的公開信」

　　作者：羽矢

　　受肖傳國欺騙而開展肖氏手術臨床試驗的肖的國外支持者，在所謂「國際學
術同仁聲援肖傳國醫生的公開信」中為肖傳國開脫，不惜歪曲、捏造有關肖氏反
射弧手術的事實，包括：

　　1. 為混淆手術「成功」的定義而稱「不能把手術的成功定義為大小便功能
恢復正常」，不顧肖傳國本人、神源醫院、肖傳國任主編的學術雜誌網站、華中
科技大學等在院士申請材料、鑒定資料、廣告宣傳中聲稱的「85％的患者大小便
已恢復正常」、「術后與常人無異，大小便能夠自控」、「像正常孩子一樣排
尿」、「獲得控尿和自主排尿功能……大便功能也轉為正常」等等。實際上，即
便在美國進行臨床試驗的Beaumont醫院的新聞發布會上，他們也自稱「（術后一
年，Beaumont醫院的）大多數患者大腦能夠接管並控制正常排尿」（in most
patients the brain was able to take over and control urination
normally.）。（見《肖氏手術的「成功」、「治癒」、「有效」
(XYS20101014)》）

　　2. 謊稱肖傳國在美國經過動物研究、結果發表並經同行驗證后才「走出了
勇敢的一步」、在中國進行人體臨床試驗。實際上，肖傳國在中國開始人體試驗
時，其大鼠實驗結果期刊論文剛剛發表一年、獲得貓實驗研究資金剛剛半年。人
體試驗開始四年後，貓實驗結果期刊論文才發表。（見《肖傳國的美國貓實驗與
中國人試驗同步進行(XYS20101005)》）

　　3. 信中謊稱「Beaumont醫院先期試驗的數據是支持肖氏手術的」，不顧其
所遭到的其結果「首次挑戰了（肖傳國）先前發表的成功率超過85%的優異結
果」、「臨床療效與肖此前所報告的截然不同」、「沒有一個能完全自主排尿，
這一事實令人困擾」等強烈質疑。（見《國外同行專家對美國肖氏手術臨床試驗
結果的評價(XYS20100930)》）

Grants awarded to Chuan-guo Xiao

SKIN-CNS-BLADDER REFLEX ARC FOR MICTURITION AFTER SCI

Chuan-guo Xiao
New York University School Of Medicine New York, Ny 10016

Grant 5R01DK053063-04 from National Institute Of Diabetes And Digestive And Kidney Diseases IRG: ZRG1

Abstract: The neurological bladder caused by spinal cord injury (SCI) presents a significant medical and social problem. There is no satisfactory treatment yet. Supported by the Paralyzed Veterans of America and NIH, a new reflex pathway, "Skin-CNS-Bladder" for controlled micturition after SCI has been successfully established in rat, cat and canine models. Preliminary clinical application of 14 SCI patients also provided very promising results. The study proposed here is to transfer the Skin-CNS-Bladder reflex functions. The ventral root (VR) of a lumbar nerve (L5) below the spinal cord lesion will be anastomosed to the sacral VR (S2 and/or S3) which innervate the bladder, while leaving the intact L5 dorsal root (DR) as a started of micturition. After the axonal regeneration, controllable voiding would be initiated by scratching the L4 dermatome. Effect of the new reflex pathway on bladder function will be evaluated by means of electrophysiology and urodynamics. Its effect on bowel and sexual functions will also be studied. The procedure may revolutionize the treatment of neurogenic bladder after SCI, It requires relatively minor surgery on 2 paralyzed nerves. It does not involve implantation of electrodes or other devices but provides unique voluntary control of bladder emptying. Scientifically, the study will further prove the new concept derived from the unique somatic-autonomic reflex that the impulses delivered from the efferent neurons of a somatic reflex arc may be transferred to initiate response of an autonomic effector. This new concept may be widely useful, not only for neurogenic bladder, but also for other problems caused by the spinal cord injury or diseases.

Keywords: electrophysiology, human therapy evaluation, neurogenic urinary bladder disorder, neuroregulation, neurosurgery, somatic reflex, spinal cord injury, urination, central nervous system, clinical trial, functional ability, outcomes research, quality of life, skin, urinary electronic stimulator, clinical research, human subject

Project start date: 1999-09-30

Project end date: 2004-12-31